All Episodes

Episode 7 · October 4, 2022 · 30 min

Ashleigh and Rachel get in a fight over squats

Listen to this episode

Show Notes

This one is spicy! In this Q&A episode, Rachel and Ashleigh start out by discussing workout and exercise order selection, but then dive deep into a fun, but respectful, debate about whether or not you should "pre-exhaust" your muscles before doing your big lifts, or whether you should keep it simple and do the big, challenging lifts first and exhaust your muscles at the end.

They also get into whether more people could benefit from machine-assisted movements or if we should prioritize old-school compound lifts with barbells. Wherever you fall in this debate, it's a good lesson that there is never a one-size-fits-all approach to fitness and that the best approach is the one that works for you.

The ladies also decide to come up with a Spotify workout playlist – if you want to send in your suggestions, email your fave songs to musclescience4women@gmail.com

If you want to sign up for the program and have Ashleigh and Rachel as your personal coaches, along with a comprehensive 12-week training plan and hours of high-level content on nutrition, training, recovery, and much more, you can sign up now by going to this link: https://www.metflexlife.com/msw

And thank you to our show sponsor, Optimal Carnivore, the makers of high-quality, nutrient-dense whole food supplements. We love their grass-fed organ complex, and you'll get 10% off your first order with the discount code MUSCLESCI on their Amazon Store: https://www.amazon.com/optimalcarnivore

Follow and learn more about Rachel at metflexlife.com and on IG at @rachelgregory.cns

Follow and learn more about Ashleigh at ashleighvanhouten.com and on IG @themusclemaven

Transcript

0:09recording okay we did it yeah that that didn't require much um swearing and heavy breathing on my end at all well you hate me right now because I'm making you do another episode it's special this is my favorite job in the world okay I don't hate it it's only a little bit all right okay when I make you talk for two hours straight listen Ashleigh was like I need to go see my kid and I haven't eaten in like 10 years and I'm sweating my um whatever off and I'm like it's fine just do another episode keep recording because it's we gotta do it for the MSW fans because they're expecting episodes I mean we gotta do it you're committed to the cause and in full transparency we were discussing how we can possibly talk about our awesome show sponsor in a um authentic way and I actually have something but this preface has made it less authentic because I'm telling you guys that anyway optimal carnivore right great great people great company they make these awesome uh grass-fed organ um pills for people who don't want to eat it right it's necessary because as I posted if you saw my funny posts on social media today that I forget having written a cookbook about organ Meats I forget like what a niche what a niche thing that still is at least in like North America

1:38right like lots of cultures of course just eat nose to tail it's fine it's not a thing but like I forget because I'm in this like small bubble of like weird meat loving Health nerds who eat this stuff I forget like how unaccepted it actually is and then like I recently spoke to like a group of literally it was like a carnivore group like a private group of carnivores and so I'm like this is about the warmest audience I'm possibly Gonna Get Right like these people are already pretty bought into the idea of eating animals pretty sure they're going to be on board with my message and like back I got they were like yeah no I don't think organ meats are good and they're disgusting and you don't need them and like they're bad and I was just like what like this is such a tough audience I thought you guys were gonna be on my side like for once I thought I was gonna have this like interaction where people were like yeah go we're in it we're into it and I was just like oh man like if I can't get the carnivores on my side I'm screwed right like I just oh my God anyway it's kind of it's kind of a it's kind of joking because of course it wasn't they weren't mean they weren't rude to me like and a lot of people were like yeah you know I try this

2:46and that and I'm willing to try but like the amount of of resistance I still got from a group of people that I'm like this is about as welcoming as like I'm gonna get it still made me think like oh yeah like I have a really really uphill battle to try to convince people to eat the most nutrient dense parts of the animals they're already eating like this is I mean listen you and I have been friends for years years we've been working together for years I still can get you to do it right that's why you're taking that's why you're taking optimal carnivore pills because you won't eat the real thing but partly that's because I haven't been there to cook anything for you so yeah that's basically it I just like someday that's gonna happen you need just need somebody to cook it for you and I I appreciate that but long story short uh for those of you who are willing to listen to me rant on and on about organ Meats but are still like you know what that's nice but no not gonna eat it you know what you can do if you care about that nutrient density if you care about eating the whole animal and you're just a little squeamish you take some of these organ Blend or liver pills from Optical carnivore it's almost as

3:55good as the real thing um and it's like a great like you were saying kind of offline too with some other stuff it's like a great insurance policy right like you just know you're getting these vitamins and minerals and stuff that our bodies need in this you know safe format and quality high quality and you don't have to prep anything you don't have to taste anything so check them out you can learn more about them um on their Amazon page it's uh amazon.com forward slash optimal carnivore and our discount code which is also in the show notes is muscle sigh so it's muscle SCI and you get 10 off if you want to try them and that's that that's that all right let's answer some questions because you're going to kill me if I keep you any longer true true story okay do you want to ask first do you want me to ask first no you were gonna ask first you have no you have the question do I oh the question was it the order the order one or the one so this person on Instagram asked she says that she does weight training and she also likes to do like running cardio biking um stuff like that what order should she be doing them to sort of optimize her results you want me to start yeah so I right off the bat I'll just say whatever your primary goal is

5:18is what you should start with it's really as simple as that you know if your primary goal is to build muscle and get stronger then that's what you want to do first um obviously getting a little warm up in getting the blood flowing going you know walking on the treadmill whatever doing a little um you know cardio get your heart rate up get that um you know just things flowing and then get into it that's that's why I recommend and then do the cardio after um or on a separate day if your goal is to run a marathon or you know I don't know Triathlon and you are really focused on the endurance side of things then do that first um but for me I would always choose the strength and lifting first and then the cardio after uh born a separate day yeah I mean I think the only thing I would add to that it's true it's like best results are what like what results are you looking to do are you looking to build muscle and get stronger you're looking to get a faster 5K time whatever um but the only thing I would add to it and to reiterate why we both believe that strength training ideally should come first is that there is sort of possibly an added safety and performance element to it where if you are doing

6:29like 30 minute like intense cardio or something first and then you go and try to like rep out some heavy squats that could be possibly problematic like you want to do the stuff that is most neurologically taxing the most technically difficult and the most just exhausting first um and it's the same reason why even within a lifting workout like you're not gonna do like Max reps of like um you know whatever they call the the quad like like extensions leg extensions you're not going to do that and then go do like three reps of Mac squats like you're gonna do the squats first because that's going to take the most work mentally and physically and it's also the thing that if you're actually exhausted and not up for it and not paying attention and not focused you could really hurt yourself you're probably not gonna have that same risk going for a run or going for a bike ride or doing some kind of cardio class or something right so it just makes sense to do those kind of bigger multi-joint heavier lifts first and then work down from there yeah I will say one thing with that is that there is something called pre-exhausting the muscles however you need to be very careful with the movement that you choose

7:41so like you were saying you know traditionally you wouldn't do leg extensions which is a quad isolation movement before a back squat especially a barbell back squat because that is still a especially if you focusing on your quads it's still going to be a full body compound movement that takes stability and internal stability to be able to do that however there is and we talk a little bit about this in the muscle environment program there are ways to if you are someone who wants to like truly like you you just want to build your quads right like that is your main goal and you want to get as much out of that as possible um then doing a pre-exhaust of like doing some light extensions and then doing a movement after that like a more lengthened movement is what a squat is when you're lengthening your quads versus the leg extension is your short the most important part of that is the shortening right the squeezing at the top however you wouldn't want to do you want to make sure that you're doing it as safely as possible as you mentioned so that would be like okay maybe I'll do a pre-exhaust leg extension right and then I'll do like a hack squat or a safety bar squat where I'm holding on so have more stability

8:50there but what's the benefit of pre-exhausting like again I hear what you're saying I don't think that it's not helpful but I think that again for like the vast majority of people would that be in any way better than doing those big lifts first and then like do it like repping out stuff at the end as like a post exhaustion like why why would presumption be better yeah so it's actually it's not necessarily better but it actually can require you to lose use less weight on that second movement right because your quads are already pre-exhausted right so you require less weight like if you were to go do a barbell back squat after you did a leg extensions which this is something that you'd have to do very lightweight and I would recommend more so using like a machine like if you do a hack squat or like a safety bar squat or have somebody spot you right um the benefit of it is you can literally you pre-exhaust basically the muscle it talks like you're what the word says pre-exhausting your quads so that when you do go to that more and and this is more so thinking about how our muscle how we're working our muscles through their ranges emotions and through their resistance profiles so with a leg extension you are it's hardest at the top

10:05when you're squeezing in that shortened position of your quad right and then a barbell back squat is hardest at the bottom when your quads are lengthened in their length in position right the stretch position you can think about I like to call these squeezers and stretchers um so with that pre-exhaust it can bring a little bit more blood flow a little bit more metabolites into the quads and actually require you to use less weight on that barbell back squat or the again I wouldn't necessarily recommend a marble basketball but any other type of compound movement where you're lengthening your quad so it could be like a leg press for example that would be a better option like doing a pre-exhaust with the leg extension and then go into a leg press machine where you have its own safety mechanism right like if you fail on a leg press you're okay like you're the bar's not going to come falling down on you right um so and again this is this is more nuanced and it's more for your maybe more experienced person right but it's also something to think about like if you are someone who doesn't really you know perform Barbara back spots well me and you don't feel your quads when you're doing them at all maybe it's

11:12like okay maybe if I take the weight off significantly and even if you're just doing the bar right if you do that after a leg extension you can really focus on getting as much knee flexion in that in that lengthen position um versus kind of you know putting a ton of weight on and your forms all over the place and you're like bouncing on the bottom and you're not going low enough to really Target your quads so it all comes back to like what your main goal is and obviously how experienced you are and also how it's worked into the programming too so a lot of these things too like it's part like it would be part of the programming um and that's where people start to like I wouldn't just like take this and go do this randomly you'd have to work it into like everything else that's everything else that's going on in my opinion okay actually clearly does not agree with well please I just feel like we made it more complicated than it needs to be I mean I'm sure there are people who again obviously someone like you too who like likes to nerd out on this stuff and and has the experience and ability to get super nuanced I think for most people it's probably not the better choice um I think it's again probably more complicated than necessary and then for people you know you

12:24know that I'm more of a purist and like people like to do they like to do the big lifts they like to do a barbell back squat so let's encourage that skill instead of this pre-exhaustion and then go use a machine thing like again if you're really focused on building quads yes you should completely program around how to best build your quads but if people are looking to just build muscle in general get good competency at these power lifts um you know whatever that kind of stuff like I don't know I just feel like it's not necessary I feel like this is a debate that we could have because I was in that camp a lot with uh not like oh using machines is for you know wimps or like I never said injured I never said that I know but I think this could be a separate episode where we talk about these are our opinions and we do talk about this a little bit in the program too like some debates there but in terms of using machines uh and actually focusing on the target muscle because like there are people and there are women out there who are like you know my quads are not like I want to build my quads I want to have nice quads right or butts right whatever I know we don't like talking about or you don't like talking about butts because I talk about it all the

13:32time well it's all day long I just don't give a about building them but in terms of just like if we're looking at like the target muscle tissue and trying to fatigue that first first versus other muscles coming in to compensate it all comes down to what your primary goal is and then also how experienced you are and like yes you'll get the most bang for your buck doing something but like maybe you've been doing that for a while and you haven't seen the results you want so maybe it's time to switch it up and try something else that's a little bit more targeted I don't know yeah yeah I mean again I don't think I don't think you've ever said anything that I outright I'm like that's and wrong and dumb like we are we are always yeah well no we that's that's our like ongoing debate which I think someday we really should do like a poll but we need you need the context and the Nuance behind it because again just like you say like you agree with me that like non-grip grip assist stuff is good and I agree with you that sometimes a grip assist is good thing but like we just are on a different s part of the scale right yeah what I'm thinking of when you're talking about this stuff and this is why you're

14:38so brilliant at program design and you that's why our program for Muscle Science for Women is better than any program I've ever seen because you nerd out on this stuff and you're really good at it however I'm thinking of it from a more high level coaching perspective where I'm I'm not necessarily always dealing with super experienced highly um like really high training age people who are looking for the Nuance of that last five ten percent of how to maximize we're looking for people who want to have fun in the gym who you know just want to squat and like want to put some weight on that bar and who maybe are frustrated with like lack of this or that or don't know what and are confused about general concepts so keeping things like again as simple as possible and letting them do their heavy Squat and anyway we're so far off with the original question was but again I just think that like your smart brain will have so many options and sometimes I'm just like just do the easiest one just do this that's why we work because it balances each other out because like with the program and it's like oh go into all these like like tiny little things that don't matter to most people and then it's like all

15:50right let's bring back some music but you still have some of that because some of it does matter too because like you said that that five percent maybe doesn't matter right now but you compound five percent on top of each other over the course of a few weeks over the course few months all that stuff like it can add up so the issue is no we're gonna keep fighting this one because the issue with that is again yes and yes I agree with you and also we know that we live in a culture where people want to focus on the five percent because people like having like little tricky hacks and like little you know special formulas for their diet that like do this little whatever five percent and they ignore the 95 like and I'm speaking about myself we've all been guilty of it but we love to like nerd out on whatever we think is interesting or whatever we think is magically gonna fix the problem because I don't actually want to deal with sleep I don't actually want to improve the squat that I've been working on half hour asked for the last 10 years and I still am not really that good at because I haven't focused on the training whatever I still am probably not eating as well as I should because I don't really want to think

16:56about it but I'll do this little thing over here because that's exciting you know what I mean so like I just think we should probably 99 of us should be focusing way less on that sexy fun cool Rabbit Hole five percent and should be focusing on like the big simple easy things that will reap the biggest rewards if we just do them but they're maybe not fun and maybe not sexy yeah yeah I'm gonna say one more thing I agree with that I'm gonna say one more thing so I and this is specific to squats and barbell back squats because here's the thing I spent many years especially as I got more into bodybuilding away from Crossfit obviously with crossover we did a lot of barbell squats but even going into bodybuilding I was like I have to squat I have to barbell squat every single week like it's part of it and I did that for the first like year and then I started working with new coach started learning more about programming learning more about like hypertrophy specific and I switched from doing barbell squats to doing hack squats and really focusing on like knee flexion and getting and really bringing my quads into it and kind of getting more nuanced with it and for me my barbell back squat has always sucked because I have ankle mobility and I have

18:09like previous injuries and low backs and Ankle stuff so like all of that together plus my sprained ankle from last month oh yeah how is that by the way are you better it's fine now yeah I've been doing a lot of in my legs and my quads going away from the barbell Squat and really focusing on the other things that I was like oh this is not like this is not gonna do it this is whatever using some pre-exhaust stuff doing some more single leg squats split squats really focusing on pushing my knees over my toes the things that you're not supposed to do really focusing on that quad uh the knee flexion to get as much quads involved as possible um and being strategic about it right and I've seen the most gains from that over doing traditional barbell squats and trying to lift as heavy as possible with those and taking my ego out of that too um so that's the only thing that from experience I'll say with the the like if your main goal is hypertrophy over strength um not that they don't happen at the same time they absolutely do we talk about this in the program but there are other things that you can do if you've been doing the same thing for so long and you're like this isn't working for me and it's not because you haven't been putting enough

19:35effort towards it it's not because um like all the other factors that are involved like you just mentioned because those are very important that 99 95 those things are important but anyway now I like we're just debating about this um I think it's something that is important because everybody is different and everybody has different goals and I think that you know just because it is maybe a little bit more more nuanced I think that if you're educated and you understand why you're doing what you're doing like that and that's what we talk about in the program like then you can use that to empower yourself and be like hey I'm going to try this out and see if this works for me and if it doesn't it doesn't but if it does then look you just got another tool in your toolbox toolbox to help you uh continue to progress so that's all I'm gonna say I mean we could keep fighting this has actually been like the probably the most heated debate we've ever had and it's super fun but yeah I mean I think ultimately some of the things that we can take away from this tirade that we've just had that people listening can be like okay that we all agree on is the idea that fundamentals and doing things well and properly and

20:43consistently is the most important and that personalized exercise selection is also crucially important because as you've just illuminated like we like to think of the squat as like the king lift that is the best for everything and sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't depending on the person and their physiology and their previous history and all those things so um you know what works for one person doesn't necessarily work for the other person um and there is a ton of room to play on the outside with all of the nuanced tweaking muscle nerd stuff that can that can bring you up to the next level most people are not there even if you think you are you probably aren't and most of us should spend most of our lives in that other 95 just working on those fundamentals because they're hard if they weren't if it wasn't difficult everybody would be perfectly healthy and fit and have no issues right most of us do struggle with one one area or another right so I think as long as you're doing it safely and you're having fun and like you said at the beginning too like mindfulness knowing what you're doing and why you're doing it having a clear sort of like path and end goal all of that stuff it's just like don't just do

22:03it because someone told you to or because some Instagram person with big quads did it or whatever or even because a coach necessarily told you like you've got to have a good sense in your head of like what are your goals what's important what feels good what is sustainable um and then you kind of take it from there but yeah I think I'm gonna call this episode um racial Rachel and Ashleigh get in a fight over squats yeah and yeah I mean I'm just gonna say one other thing too like if you or someone out there who has been barbell back squatting for a while and it's and you just don't like doing it you do not have to barbel back squat to build your legs and I made that mistake for years because some of us don't have the structure to be able to optimize that but I'm just gonna say that if you hate barbell back squatting you don't have to do it I don't think anybody has to squat if I was gonna say if I was gonna say one thing everybody should do lunges okay okay those are the that's the good right there and a lot most people I feel like can probably do lunges I feel like that's a technically easier movement and there's so much you can do with that but listen we should have like a series where we just like debate different exercises okay great and like episode one squads

23:23I think they're fine and Rachel wants to throw them in a fire apparently I don't but like I just there's just so much anyway they're fine it's fine they're fine it's fine it's fine do them if you like it smoke them if you got them I don't know whatever live your life like Rihanna live your life Rihanna told us to live our lives so let's do it I feel like that's the end of this episode you're gonna ask another question but I feel like I feel like okay well we did into our update we didn't do our five minute update so let's finish with two minutes each you go Ashleigh if you just saw her face right now she's literally about to like ignore me literally got to murder me wait maybe maybe I'll pull something interesting out of my brain that's going on in my life um okay how she can buy a gun to human face no I live in Canada so I don't really care about that um I don't we don't have guns up here okay uh okay okay but you're in San Diego so it's also the same okay this is going off the rails here's something I just very early ordered a Halloween costume for my son because he's at the age where I can just put him in ridiculous stuff and it's really cute and it's like purely for my enjoyment and I bought him a like relatively

24:32realistic sea turtle costume oh my God and it's the cutest thing I've ever seen I haven't put them in it yet and I think it's actually way too big so it might be like a whole nightmare but I'm really really excited to put my little baby in a sea turtle costume and just like parade him around oh my God please send me the first video 100 100 he's gonna hate it probably but it's fine it's two seconds I gave birth to him I can put him in a turtle costume do it yep okay um now I don't even know what my update is why'd I do this I'm sorry I got a car I bought a car oh okay yeah have you not had a car in San Diego um I Alex had a car and I had a car when we first moved here but I didn't use it at all because I walked everywhere and probably now I'm gonna use this car but we ended up getting it was this like on Sunday we ended up getting like a really good deal and we're like oh we're just gonna go go to these different you know dealers and just like you know mess around not gonna buy anything what did we do ended up buying something um and it's like You're gonna laugh it's it's an Audi nice okay super like bougie like whatever and I'm just like I told myself like I'm never gonna buy like a nice like a car like this I don't need this like

25:50whatever it's a car like I'm just gonna stick with like a Toyota RAV4 and then we actually ended up going and looking at Toyota RAV4s and also looking at some other ones and we got a better deal on this Audi because I don't know why but I feel like first of all we bought it a little we got bought it used it was just a loaner vehicle it's not brand new but it feels brand new and I think that like people don't think that they can I don't know afford the the Audi or the nicer cars so they're all they've all been going to like Toyota and because the inventory is so weird right now it's like the Toyota RAV4s are like like flying off the shelf and so they're like more expensive and then like the other dealerships like the Audis and stuff like that are like they have more inventory I don't know this is just a theory so like those prices are like a little bit lower I don't know whatever I don't really know that much about car stuff so anyway bought a car and it yeah it was a first thing I've ever owned from that type of perspective here's my question is it a hybrid it's not okay so because we're fighting in this episode I want to bring to attention that you gave me for drinking out of a plastic Nalgene bottle the other day but you're not even trying

27:00to buy a hybrid car okay I tried oh hybrid yes they have the hybrids and I look they didn't have any available okay so all right just keep using gas and murder murder our planet listen uh when you said you weren't gonna arrive at that much I mean where would you go in the car because you you're big on walking anyway right like I know it's only for like the weekends going different place or like driving up to my sisters or whatever so yeah because there's not that's why I leased a car when I first got here it was a RAV4 okay and it literally sat in the garage for three years and had like 4 000 miles on it not even after three years so we have like an old Mazda but we actually went a full year like we don't live in a place that's like super conducive to not having a car I mean we have a great neighborhood that we don't really need to walk much but we always had a car um and then we didn't have a car for like a year and we only got one because the baby and we figured like emergency purposes it would probably be like safe to have a car a child um but we're thinking like when this car it's a used one um when this one like dies will probably look like hopefully in the coming years there will be a lot more um options for like hybrid vehicles and stuff and

28:15so anyway um we'll see what happens but cars are they're like it's nice to have but they are such a um money suck right like as soon as you buy it it's like worthless and then you just have to take care of it it's like a whole thing anyway yeah yeah right well congrats on your Audi I guess you're like a cool big deal now you gotta just yeah yeah okay when I come visit you can take me on a joy ride somewhere cool yes please also like I'm not like oh like this is like I have this like nice ass car like whatever it was a really good deal I bought it used and the the idea is that it will hold its value um to potentially resell in the future and do some other stuff so whatever just don't judge me I don't care you need to treat yourself okay you need to treat yourself you deserve it you're a hard worker you know what this this brings to mind though that we should do now because I'm thinking about us being in a car together and driving and the potential like the playlist the playlist that we'd be listening to and I feel like you and I would probably have like you know a a playlist that we could both agree on but we should probably come up with that now like our top like 10 either driving in the car songs or like at the

29:29gym songs that would probably be the video do you use Spotify oh yeah oh yeah okay so we can create a playlist on Spotify oh my God we can call it the MSW workout playlist Banger oh okay this is so good okay this is great and then we can even see if like we can crowdsource some listeners and see if they have any suggestions for us ooh this is so good okay all right love it love it send your suggestions to Muscle Science for Women gmail.com if you have any bangers that you think we should add to our playlist love it and yeah see you next time guys oh my God